Welcome to First Basemen Rankings Week! A position so “easy” to play, that everyone effing hates playing it. A position that gets you docked 50 spots on real life prospect lists just for funsies. A position where old catchers get to live out their best life in their declining years. And a position where fake catchers go to thrive. I’m going over 90 deep on the Patreon. Top 5 free here on the Brick Wall. Here is the 2027 Deep Dynasty Baseball Positional Rankings: Top 90+ First Basemen:
CLICK HERE TO JOIN MY PATREON FOR THE REST OF THESE RANKS & TONS OF EXCLUSIVE CONTENT ALL OFF-SEASON, INCLUDING:
-A TOP 75 SNEAK PEEK OF THE 2027 TOP 1,000 DYNASTY BASEBALL RANKS
–TOP 36 2027 FYPD RANKS (full Top 130+ coming later this off-season)
-A TOP 17 SNEAK PEEK OF THE 2027 TOP 500 PROSPECTS RANKS
-2027 DEEP POSITIONAL RANKINGS: Top 81 Catchers–Top 90+ 1B
-DYNASTY TEAM REPORTS (TOP 10 PROSPECTS/INTERESTING MLB GUYS/STRATEGY SECTION)
-POSITION BY POSITION TARGET ARTICLES (Upcoming)
-PREDICTING FUTURE PROSPECT LISTS (Upcoming)
-SPREADSHEETS
-AND SO MUCH MORE
Previous Dynasty Team Reports on Patreon
Atlanta Braves—Baltimore Orioles—Chicago White Sox—Kansas City Royals—Milwaukee Brewers (free)—Minnesota Twins (free)—New York Mets (free)—Philadelphia Phillies—Pittsburgh Pirates—Sacramento Athletics—Tampa Bay Rays—Toronto Blue Jays—Washington Nationals
1) Nick Kurtz – SAC, 1B, 24.1 – Can we just take a second to acknowledge how cool it is that baseball stats on Fangraphs go back to 1871. Like, some dudes that fought in the Civil War have a fucking Fangraphs page hah. Am I the only one blown away by that? In 1871, the league strikeout rate was 1.6%. That was how real men played baseball. Not these modern day pansies like Nick Kurtz who struck out 32.5% of the time. He whiffed 36.9% of the time. Robert E. Lee would be appalled at these strikeouts rates. Ulysses S. Grant is rolling over in his grave. But the year is 2026, and no matter how many people bemoan the state of the strikeout or homer game, that is how it is. Even with all that swing and miss, Kurtz has a .275 career BA in 923 PA (.256 this year), and if you don’t buy into that, his .244 xBA really isn’t that bad with how many dingers he’s going to hit you. He smashes the ball so damn hard with a 57.3% Hard Hit%, and the 18.2% BB% definitely mitigates a large chunk of that swing and miss. He also chipped in with 7 steals in 99 games which is not too shabby. He’s just so damn fun that I can’t bring myself to fade him because of the concerning whiff rates, but obviously if the BA does tank, the big red flag was waving right in our faces. – 2027 Projection: 100/37/105/.252/.370/.533/8
2) Ben Rice – NYY, 1B, 28.1 – Can I just get a moment of silence to mourn the loss of Rice’s catcher eligibility ……… thank you, you may be seated. In my 18 team points league where he led me to a championship, he lapped the field compared to other catchers with 1,225.8 points (the next highest was Drake Baldwin at 980.9 points). As a 1B, he wasn’t even #1, that was Alonso, and there were 5 other guys who put up 1100+ and 7 other guys on top of that who put over 1000. Having Rice at catcher was truly a separator, but we can’t be greedy. He was actually worse from an underlying numbers perspective in 2026 than 2025 with his xwOBA dropping from .391 to .378, but after getting unlucky the first two years of his career, he answered the question of “what would a lucky Ben Rice season look like?” And it looks like 41 homers with a .384 wOBA. That is very clearly on the high end of his ability as his EV, Hard Hit%, and Air Pull% all dropped to less eye popping levels, but still really damn good, and the xwOBA was still good for tied for 9th best in baseball. This is straight up one of the best hitters in the game, and he deserves massive respect no matter what position he plays. – 2027 Projection: 98/35/95/.260/.355/.515/3
3) Sal Stewart – CIN, 1B/3B, 23.4 – I can honestly say that in the nearly 11 years since I started writing, I never received more pushback on a ranking than when I ranked Sal Stewart 12th overall on April 21st in the Updated April Dynasty Baseball Rankings. And while he doesn’t rank 12th overall for me today, and while people were right that I was likely too aggressive, I do feel a bit vindicated that he finished the season 14th overall on the CBS Player Rater. Yes, I usually reference the Razzball Player Rater, but they have him 18th, so the CBS one sounds better for me ;). But finishing 18th overall as a 22 year old in his rookie season still clearly shows I was far from crazy for my lofty ranking. Too aggressive? Yes. But the sentiment was still correct. Which was that this is a special dynasty bat. There is honestly nothing too gaudy in his underlying numbers, but he’s a complete hitter who does everything well at the plate and hits in one of the best ballparks in baseball. His swing is geared for both average and power. He has strong plate skills which were basically elite in the minors, so my expectation is that those are only going to improve. And despite below average speed, he stole 15 bags. Stolen bases are the thing that is truly holding me up from going even higher on him right now. He got caught 8 times and he ran much less in the 2nd half. It’s definitely a tad concerning that the steals could dry up, but I don’t think it’s guaranteed to happen. He was a good base stealer in the minors and he does fit the profile of a guy who is going to steal bags despite below average speed. The profile might not scream elite superstar in any one area, but this dude is going to be putting up impactful fantasy season after impactful fantasy season for the next decade. – 2027 Projection: 89/28/100/.273/.345/.478/14
4) Bryce Eldridge – SFG, 1B, 22.5 – People were staring to get some cold feet with Eldridge after his rough small sample MLB debut in 2025, but I implored you to not budge on his value, ranking him 108th overall in the 2026 Top 1,000 and writing, “If someone is going to Nick Kurtz the majors in 2026, it’s going to be Eldridge. I think people forget that Kurtz had a .558 OPS with a 36.5% K% in his first 85 PA in the majors. People were getting nervous. But that is all obviously a distant memory now, just as Eldridge’s rough MLB debut (.476 OPS with a 35.1% K%) will soon be a distant memory. And Eldridge’s only came in 37 PA as a 20 year old. Completely throw out that debut. The only other quibbles to the profile are that he’s not a lift and pull machine, but he doesn’t have to be with that level of power, and he’s going to the 3rd worst park for lefty homers, but his power is ballpark proof. Eldridge is setting up to be one of the best power hitters in the game for a long time.” … and while he didn’t go full Kurtz, he was damn good in 2026, slashing .269/.364/.461 with 17 homers, 1 steal, and a 26.6/13.2 K%/BB% in 107 games. The most impressive thing by far was how good the hit tool was with a 27.1% whiff%, and while I don’t completely trust that is he true talent level, it does take a huge portion of the hit tool concerns away. He was also ballpark proof like I mentioned with 10 homers and a .836 OPS in 53 games at home. And of course he smoked the ball with a 92.7 MPH EV and 52.2% Hard Hit%. We couldn’t have asked for a better 21 year old season. Even if he can’t tap into more lift/pull, a 13.7 degree launch and 15.9% Air Pull% is more than enough for him to be an easy 30+ homer bat, and it will keep the BA high too. If he does lift/pull more, a perennial 40+ homer bat is in play. He’s going to be one of the top power hitters in the major for a long, long time. – 2027 Projection: 87/32/99/.260/.355/.485/3
5) Pete Alonso – BAL, 1B, 32.5 – Alonso just messed around and had arguably the best year of his career at age 31. The 148 wRC+ in a career high. The .402 xwOBA is a career high. The 56.2% Hard Hit% is a career high. The .363 OBP is a career high. Even the 5 steals tied a career high. And of course, he jacked out 43 homers with a .267 BA. He stays healthy and plays in nearly every game. He’s as consistent as they come, and while he’s getting up there in age at 32 years old, there are zero signs of decline. And like I wrote, actually the opposite of zero signs of decline. He’s getting better. – 2027 Projection: 93/39/115/.263/.355/.520/3
CLICK HERE TO JOIN MY PATREON FOR THE REST OF THESE RANKS & TONS OF EXCLUSIVE CONTENT ALL OFF-SEASON, INCLUDING:
-A TOP 75 SNEAK PEEK OF THE 2027 TOP 1,000 DYNASTY BASEBALL RANKS
–TOP 36 2027 FYPD RANKS (full Top 130+ coming later this off-season)
-A TOP 17 SNEAK PEEK OF THE 2027 TOP 500 PROSPECTS RANKS
-2027 DEEP POSITIONAL RANKINGS: Top 81 Catchers–Top 90+ 1B
-DYNASTY TEAM REPORTS (TOP 10 PROSPECTS/INTERESTING MLB GUYS/STRATEGY SECTION)
-POSITION BY POSITION TARGET ARTICLES (Upcoming)
-PREDICTING FUTURE PROSPECT LISTS (Upcoming)
-SPREADSHEETS
-AND SO MUCH MORE
Previous Dynasty Team Reports on Patreon
Atlanta Braves—Baltimore Orioles—Chicago White Sox—Kansas City Royals—Milwaukee Brewers (free)—Minnesota Twins (free)—New York Mets (free)—Philadelphia Phillies—Pittsburgh Pirates—Sacramento Athletics—Tampa Bay Rays—Toronto Blue Jays—Washington Nationals
By Michael Halpern (@MichaelCHalpern)
Email: michaelhalpern@imaginarybrickwall.com
Twitter: Imaginary Brick Wall (@DynastyHalp)
Blue Sky: Dynasty Halp (@ImaginaryBrickWall)