Thanks!

Hey Duda! Deal looks pretty fair to me. Don’t have a strong preference to either side. I guess I lean the Eloy and Scherzer side as you would be buying Rendon and Bieber coming off the best seasons on their career so far. I would probably want to look to trade Scherzer on his own.

PS – same league as above…Meadows trade partner bailed, but was able to flip JDM for the trio of eloy, chapman, and $12 Glasnow (who’s currently odd man out).

My $7 eloy and a $34 Scherzer

For his $22 rendon and $16 bieber.

My other 5 keepers are Acuna (29) Yelich (50) Story (16) Villar (8) Chapman (7).

Do you have a strong preference towards either side?

Thanks!

Awesome. Thanks, Casey

It was a tough call. Hopefully I can make up for it this season.

No problem, I enjoy your site. I have Tatis as well, and at the time was not 100% who exactly was going to play SS/3B, and figure having both would hedge against the other on my team.

My bad. Looking back I had Arenado 14 and Machado 10. Arenado was coming off a career worst K% while Machado hit a career best (I don’t recall questioning Arenado’s power though). I’m happy with the Arenado ranking but ended up being too high on Machado in hindsight. Didn’t expect the BA to fall off so much. But I do like him to bounce back this year and he could easily outdo Arenado, especially with Arenado’s trade rumors. I had a lot of good calls in last years ranking, but only fair to take my lumps for the bad ones too.